Marleybones vs Lily's Kitchen: Which Is Right for Your Dog?
At a Glance
| Category | Marleybones | Lily's Kitchen (Fresh Recipes) |
| Food Format | Pantry Fresh®, shelf-stable carton, ready to serve | Fresh Recipes, cupboard-stable pouch, ready to serve |
| Cooking Method | Sealed raw and gently slow-cooked in-pack | Gently cooked and sealed in-pouch |
| Meat Content | 60% freshly prepared meat or fish | 60% freshly prepared meat |
| Life Stage | Complete for all life stages, including puppies | For adult dogs from 4 months+ |
| Personalisation | Quiz-led, dog-specific plan | No personalised plan; fixed taster and selection packs |
| Preservatives | None: no artificial preservatives, kept shelf-stable by the cooking method | None: no artificial preservatives, cupboard-stable via their cooking method |
| Vet-Backed | Yes: vet-developed, complete and FEDIAF compliant | Yes: vet-approved, complete and balanced |
| Storage | Cupboard until opened (up to 18 months); refrigerate and use within 48 hours once open | Cupboard until opened; refrigerate and use within 2 days once open |
| Packaging | Recyclable, plant-based carton; plastic neutral certified | Recyclable pouch (follow on-pack instructions) |
| Price (list) | £3.50 / 390g carton (£0.90 per 100g) | £3.95 / 300g pouch (£1.32 per 100g) |
| Availability | Online plan + Waitrose, Ocado, Pets at Home, Co-op | Own website + major UK supermarkets and pet retailers |
| Trustpilot | 4.9/5 (1000+ reviews) | 4.7/5 (15,000+ reviews) |
| Best For | Owners who want a personalised, all-life-stages fresh plan with no freezer | Owners who want a trusted, widely stocked brand they can pick up in the supermarket |
Brand Overviews
Marleybones
Founded in London by Josephine and Mikala, and named after their golden cocker spaniel Marley, Marleybones is a female-founded, vet-backed fresh dog food brand built around the Pantry Fresh® format.
Meals are sealed raw and slow-cooked in-pack, making them shelf-stable without any preservatives and ready to serve straight from the carton. Every recipe contains 60% freshly prepared meat or fish, three vegetables, and seven functional superfoods, including chicory root, a natural prebiotic that supports gut health as standard in every meal. Recipes are complete for all life stages, including puppies, and customers complete a short quiz to receive a personalised plan or buy as they go. Plastic neutral certified, Marleybones has delivered over 2 million meals and holds a 4.9/5 Trustpilot rating.
Lily's Kitchen
Lily's Kitchen is an established UK natural pet food brand, founded in 2008 and a certified B Corp, with wide distribution across major supermarkets and pet retailers. Alongside its established wet and dry ranges, Fresh Recipes is its move into cupboard-fresh food: gently cooked, freshly prepared meat pouches that are shelf-stable until opened, currently sold as a three-recipe taster and a larger selection pack.
The range is built around three chicken-based recipes, made with natural ingredients and no artificial preservatives, complete and balanced for adult dogs from four months. Lily's Kitchen holds a 4.7/5 Trustpilot rating from over 15,000 reviews.
Marleybones vs Lily's Kitchen: A Detailed Comparison
Food and Format: Two Takes on Cupboard-Fresh
Marleybones
Marleybones meals come in recyclable, plant-based cartons that are shelf-stable until opened. Open the carton and serve, with no prep and no freezer.
Lily's Kitchen
Lily's Kitchen Fresh Recipes come in recyclable pouches that are also cupboard-stable until opened, then kept in the fridge once open. They are ready to serve with no freezing.
Summary: Both are cupboard-fresh and need no freezer. Marleybones serves from a recyclable, plant-based carton and Lily's Kitchen from a recyclable pouch, and both go straight from pack to bowl.
Ingredients and Nutrition
Marleybones
Every Marleybones meal contains 60% freshly prepared meat or fish, three vegetables, and seven functional superfoods including chicory root, chia seeds, hemp seed, linseed, quinoa, seaweed and rosemary. There are no artificial preservatives, additives or fillers, and the same prebiotic and superfood blend features in every recipe.
Lily's Kitchen
Lily's Kitchen Fresh Recipes also use 60% freshly prepared meat across three chicken-based recipes, with vegetables, fruit and botanicals, and no artificial preservatives.
Summary: Both brands use 60% freshly prepared meat, prepared fresh rather than as meal or from frozen, with no artificial additives. The difference is in the blend: Marleybones builds the same seven superfoods and a natural prebiotic into every recipe and is formulated for all life stages, while Lily's Kitchen offers three chicken-based recipes for adult dogs.
Personalisation
Marleybones
Every Marleybones customer completes a short quiz covering their dog's breed, age, weight and activity level. The result is a personalised plan with the right recipes and portions for that dog, delivered on a schedule, with recipes also available to buy individually.
Lily's Kitchen
Lily's Kitchen Fresh Recipes are sold as fixed packs, a three-recipe taster and a larger selection, rather than a personalised plan. Owners choose the pack and manage portions themselves.
Summary: Marleybones matches recipes and portions to the individual dog from the start. Lily's Kitchen Fresh Recipes are a self-select taster and selection format.
Price
Marleybones Boss Beef is £3.50 for a 390g carton, which works out at £0.90 per 100g. Lily's Kitchen Fresh Recipes are £3.95 for a 300g pouch, or £1.32 per 100g. Buying Lily's Kitchen in its larger multipacks brings its price down to around £1.17 per 100g, still above Marleybones.
Summary: On list price Marleybones is cheaper, whether you compare by the pack or per 100g, though the daily cost for any dog depends on their portion size.
Sustainability and Packaging
Marleybones
Marleybones uses recyclable, plant-based cartons and is plastic neutral certified, removing as much plastic from the environment as it unavoidably uses.
Lily's Kitchen
Lily's Kitchen is a certified B Corp with a long-standing natural food mission, and its Fresh Recipes pouches are recyclable via the instructions on pack.
Summary: Both take sustainability seriously. Marleybones is plastic neutral with a plant-based carton, and Lily's Kitchen holds B Corp certification across its business and uses a recyclable pouch.
Customer Satisfaction
Marleybones
4.9/5 on Trustpilot from over 1,000 reviews. Common themes: fussy dogs clearing their bowls, improved digestion and coat condition, and the simplicity of a no-prep, no-freezer format.
Lily's Kitchen
4.7/5 on Trustpilot from more than 15,000 reviews, reflecting a long and established track record. Customers highlight ingredient quality, palatability and reliable delivery.
Summary: Marleybones holds the higher rating and Lily's Kitchen the far larger review base built over many years. Both are well regarded by owners.
Availability: Where Can You Buy It?
Marleybones
Marleybones is available online via subscription and as one-off orders, and is stocked in Waitrose, Ocado, Pets at Home and Co-op.
Lily's Kitchen
Lily's Kitchen is available from its own website and is widely stocked across major UK supermarkets and pet retailers.
Summary: Both are easy to buy online and in-store. Lily's Kitchen has broader supermarket distribution, while Marleybones is stocked in Waitrose, Ocado, Pets at Home and Co-op alongside its online plan.
Which Is Right for You?
Marleybones may suit you better if:
- You want the food built around your dog rather than the other way round: the quiz sets the recipes, portions and delivery schedule for their breed, age, weight and activity, and adjusts as they change
- You want fresh food that is complete for all life stages, including puppies
- Your dog has a sensitive stomach, with a natural prebiotic in every recipe as standard
- You want the cheaper option pack-for-pack, in a plastic neutral, plant-based carton, ready to serve with no freezer
Lily's Kitchen may suit you better if:
- You want a long-established, widely stocked brand with B Corp certification
- You want the option to mix fresh with a wider wet and dry range from one brand
- You want to pick it up in the supermarket alongside your weekly shop
“Such a relief to see her enjoying her food”
FAQs
Does Marleybones need to be frozen?
No. Marleybones meals are Pantry Fresh® and shelf-stable, stored in a cupboard until opened, with no freezing or thawing at any point. Once open, keep any unused portion in the fridge and serve within a couple of days.
What is the difference between Marleybones and Lily's Kitchen Fresh Recipes?
Both are cupboard-fresh foods that need no freezer, and both use 60% freshly prepared meat. Marleybones is a personalised, quiz-led plan that is complete for all life stages, with seven superfoods and a natural prebiotic in every recipe. Lily's Kitchen Fresh Recipes are three chicken-based recipes for adult dogs, sold as a taster and selection rather than a personalised plan.
Is Marleybones or Lily's Kitchen cheaper?
Marleybones. Boss Beef is £3.50 for a 390g carton (£0.90 per 100g), while Lily's Kitchen Fresh Recipes are £3.95 for a 300g pouch (£1.32 per 100g), so Marleybones is cheaper, whether you compare the packs directly or per 100g. Daily cost depends on your dog's size and portion, so it is worth checking each brand's pricing for your dog.
Is Marleybones suitable for puppies and all life stages?
Yes. All Marleybones recipes are vet-developed and complete for all life stages, including puppies, with every plan portioned to the individual dog. Lily's Kitchen Fresh Recipes are formulated for adult dogs from four months.
Is Marleybones or Lily's Kitchen better for dogs with sensitive stomachs?
Marleybones includes chicory root, a natural prebiotic, in every recipe as standard, supporting gut health through whole-food nutrition. Lily's Kitchen Fresh Recipes use natural ingredients with no artificial additives.
Where can I buy Marleybones?
Marleybones is available online via a personalised subscription and as one-off orders, and is stocked in Waitrose, Ocado, Pets at Home and Co-op.
Give your dog the quality nutrition they deserve
Real meat, wholesome veggies and functional superfoods.
Get 40% OFF today
